A recent BeautyMatter article titled “Many shades, same blind spot” explores the gap between shade proliferation and match satisfaction stating that makeup’s inclusivity race is solving the wrong problem.
Depth and undertone are two separate variables, but whilst depth has propelled the inclusivity race and the era of the 40+ shade foundation range, complaints about undertone mismatch persist. According to BeautyMatter, an internal study by Shiseido even found that 94% of women are wearing the wrong shade of foundation.
The Missing Piece in Accurate Shade Matching
Until now, undertone has not garnered the same attention as shade count. The good news for consumers and brands is that a recalibration seems to be taking place, and illuminateAI is playing an important role in this narrative. IlluminateAI is the first and only software that accurately and instantly measures both skin tone and undertone – and ends the undertone guessing.
Undertone mismatch can be an enigma for both consumers and brands. BeautyMatter states that “every expert interviewed said that consumers and even brands conflate depth (how light or dark a shade is) with undertone (its underlying color cast).” illuminateAI agrees with Dianna Ruth’s (DMI Solutions) point that “more education about undertones would be a benefit to the complexion category in general”. Visual AI and a spectroscopy-based (the scientific study of how matter intersects with light) approach can cut through much of the complexity that impairs undertone understanding.
Understanding Undertone
As BeautyMatter puts it: “Depth is easy to see. Undertone is where brands lose the sale”. Beyond confusion between depth and undertone, underlying issues such as surface redness can lead to skin undertone misidentification.
The struggle is clear.
Accurately identifying a consumer’s unique depth and undertone is the first challenge.
The second is navigating a world of shade ranges without any universal shade numbering or universal undertone naming systems.
The third is factoring in all four variables: depth, undertone, finish and formula. For example undertone’s effect on a shade can vary between formulas.
With 73% of women struggling to find the right foundation (NPD), it is clear that major challenges persist.
From a brand perspective, BeautyMatter succinctly points out that “every additional shade represents R&D spend, packaging SKUs, inventory, and markdown risk”. There is a huge opportunity for smarter ranges, not just bigger ones. Undertone diversity is critical to this narrative, and illuminateAI’s technology can support upstream R&D efforts with unique data and insights such as product to skin mapping.
IlluminateAI Provides an Unlock for Undertone
Downstream, illuminateAI is helping consumers and brands avoid persistent mismatch issues. By actually instantly measuring skin undertone, and pairing that measurement with a deep understanding of depth, undertone, formula and finish, illuminateAI provides an accurate shade match in under 60 seconds. For example the Clarins Shade Finder has a 96% match rate compared to a professional makeup artist.
Through the ease of a selfie, illuminateAI scientifically measures a consumer’s depth and undertone and maps this to a proprietary database of shades. illuminateAI then models product-skin interaction and provides the best shade match to the consumer.
Through accurate, scientifically validated measurements of both skin and products, illuminateAI is o demystifying the enigma of undertone diversity and naming through a new data-driven, industry first approach.
Undertone was always the missing piece in the inclusivity race, and it’s finally getting the attention it deserves.